Home › Example budgets by situation
Year one in a 1970s house: a $6,400 budget with a maintenance reserve
Illustrative example. This is an illustrative example, not a real household, and not a real house. Nobody was interviewed for this page. The income, the repair costs and the escrow figure were chosen by us to demonstrate the arithmetic. They are not price quotes and not claims about what repairs cost. Get your own quotes.
An illustrative couple splits $6,400 into 12 envelopes, including a $400 monthly home maintenance reserve that funds $4,800 across year one. In this example that reserve absorbs $600 of month-one tools, a water heater replacement in month three, and an escrow shortfall in month seven without a card balance.
The breakdown
| Envelope | Amount | % |
|---|---|---|
|
🏠 Mortgage, taxes and insurance
One escrowed payment. Recompute it whenever the servicer reanalyzes. |
$2,250 | 35% |
|
🛒 Groceries
Two adults, most meals at home. |
$780 | 12% |
|
🪺 Retirement contribution
Placement decision only. Not investment advice. |
$640 | 10% |
|
🚗 Transportation
Two cars including insurance, gas and routine service. |
$560 | 9% |
|
🩺 Insurance premiums
Health and related coverage. This page does not tell you what to buy. |
$480 | 8% |
|
🔧 Home maintenance reserve
The envelope this whole page is about. $4,800 over year one. |
$400 | 6% |
|
🍿 Personal and fun
Two people, split however you like. |
$320 | 5% |
|
🏦 Debt payments
Car loan and anything else with a fixed monthly number. |
$310 | 5% |
|
💡 Utilities
A 1970s house costs more to heat and cool than the apartment did. |
$320 | 5% |
|
🛟 Emergency fund
Separate from the maintenance reserve, on purpose. |
$145 | 2% |
|
📱 Phone and internet
Flat and boring. |
$145 | 2% |
|
🪚 Tools and furnishing (year one)
$600 across year one, then this line ends. |
$50 | 1% |
Total assigned: $6,400 of $6,400 monthly take-home — every amount has a job.
The setup
Two adults, $6,400 of take-home, and a house built in the 1970s that passed inspection with the usual list of things described as fine for now. The first-year problem is that the mortgage payment is the only cost anyone plans for, and it happens to be the one cost that behaves. Everything else about a house arrives unscheduled, in the wrong order, and frequently in a week when something else already went wrong. You cannot forecast which system fails, and pretending otherwise produces a spreadsheet that is wrong in a specific and confident way. This budget answers that with a single boring envelope, funded from month one, whose entire job is to already exist before you know what it is for.
Where the $6,400 goes
The escrowed mortgage payment takes $2,250. Groceries are $780, retirement $640, transportation $560, insurance premiums $480, utilities $320, personal and fun $320, debt payments $310. Phone and internet and the emergency fund are $145 each. The maintenance reserve gets $400 a month, and a temporary tools-and-furnishing line gets $50, which ends after year one and then moves to the emergency fund. Total: $6,400. The reserve is 6.25 percent of take-home, which is a decision this example made rather than a rule anyone can hand you. Notice that utilities jumped from the apartment number, since a fifty-year-old house is not insulated like a two-bedroom on a middle floor, and that is a permanent change rather than a first-year surprise.
Month one: the tools you did not know you needed
A mower, a ladder, a decent drill, a hose, a shovel, an extension cord, the fifth trip to the hardware store for the specific fitting. In this example that is about $600 across the year, funded at $50 a month, and the reason it gets its own line rather than coming out of the maintenance reserve is that these are one-time purchases with no repeat. Mixing them into the reserve makes the reserve look busier than it is and hides how much genuine repair capacity you have. In month thirteen the line ends and the $50 moves to the emergency fund.
Month three: the water heater
It goes on a Tuesday, and you find out because the shower is cold. Assume the replacement lands at $1,600 in your market, which is an assumption to replace with real quotes rather than a number to trust from a web page. The reserve has three months of fills, $1,200, so you are $400 short and you cover it from the emergency fund, then rebuild. That is not a failure of the plan. That is the plan working: the interaction is a transfer between two of your own envelopes, decided in an afternoon, instead of a card balance you are still looking at in December.
Month seven: the escrow analysis
A letter arrives saying the taxes and insurance the servicer paid on your behalf cost more than they collected. In this example the shortfall is $340, and the monthly payment resets upward from that point. Two things have to happen. The $340 comes out of the reserve, and the mortgage envelope gets recomputed from the new statement, which means something else in the budget shrinks by the difference this month rather than next quarter. This is why the reserve is not only for broken things. It is for the house costing more than the closing paperwork implied, which is common and not a crisis if it has a funding source.
The same year, without the reserve
Same house, same three events, no envelope. Month one, the tools go on a card. Month three, the water heater joins them. Month seven, the escrow shortfall arrives while the card balance is still there and the payment has just gone up. Nothing catastrophic has happened and the household is now carrying a balance it did not plan, made of purchases it could not have avoided. The difference between the two versions of the year is not income, luck or discipline. It is $400 a month set aside starting in month one, before there was anything to set it aside for.
Common questions
How big should a maintenance reserve be?
There are popular rules of thumb and we are not going to repeat one as if it were established fact, because they vary and none of them knows your house. A better method: list the major systems, note roughly how old each is and what a replacement would cost from local quotes, divide each by the years you expect to get, and add them up. That gives you a defensible monthly number tied to your actual roof, heater and appliances rather than a percentage someone chose because it was memorable.
What if the reserve is empty when something breaks?
You borrow from the emergency fund, as in month three of this example, then rebuild the reserve first before resuming any optional envelope. The important part is deciding that order in advance, while nothing is broken. Households that have not decided tend to reach for a card, because at 8 p.m. with no hot water a card is the path of least resistance. A named, pre-agreed backup envelope removes that decision from the moment when you are least able to make it.
Should the reserve and the emergency fund be the same envelope?
Keeping them separate is more useful because they answer different questions. The reserve answers 'is the house on track', and its balance should cycle up and down as things get repaired. The emergency fund answers 'can this household absorb a shock', and it should mostly grow. Combined, a busy repair year makes it look like you have no emergency fund, and a quiet one makes it look like you have more capacity than you do.
What counts as maintenance rather than improvement?
A workable line: maintenance keeps the house doing what it already did, improvement makes it do something new or nicer. The water heater is maintenance. A new backsplash is not. This matters for budgeting because improvements are optional and can be planned into their own sinking fund with a target and a date, while maintenance is not optional and needs a standing reserve. Blending them tends to mean the improvement gets funded and the failing system does not.
Run this budget on your phone
Envelope Budget puts these envelopes in your pocket. Assign every amount, log spending as it happens, and see what is actually left.
Get Envelope BudgetiPhone · manual entry, no bank connection · 7-day free trial